| 1840 |
Rev. Flavel Bascom
Founding Missionary |
| 1842-1844 |
Rev. E. G. Howe |
| 1844 |
Rev. Parker |
| 1844-1862 |
Rev. William Bradford Dodge |
| 1863-1864 |
Rev. Calvin Selden |
| 1864-1867 |
Rev. Harmon Bross |
| 1867-1870 |
Rev. Thomas Lightbody |
| 1870 |
Rev. Noyes |
| 1871 |
Rev. E. B. Payne |
| 1871-1873 |
Rev. J. H. Parker |
| 1873-1874 |
Rev. W. B. Millard |
| 1874-1880 |
Rev. C. M. Bingham |
| 1881-1883 |
Rev. James Campbell |
| 1883-1887 |
Rev. Victor H. Clark |
| 1887-1890 |
Rev. Norman A. Millard |
| 1890-1893 |
Rev. S. G. Arnett |
| 1893-1900 |
Rev. Sheldon A. Harris |
| 1901-1902 |
Rev. George Mitchell |
| 1903-1904 |
Rev. Frank T. Lee |
| 1905-1919 |
Rev. Albert W. Safford |
| 1920 |
Rev. A. H. Ford |
| 1920-1923 |
Rev. Stephen C. Fooks |
| 1923-1925 |
Rev. Norman L. Rice |
| 1925-1927 |
Rev. A. H. Bartter |
| 1927-1928 |
Rev. Everett W. McNair |
| 1928-1932 |
Rev. A. H. Pierstorff |
| 1933-1939 |
Rev. Samuel Holden |
| 1939-1941 |
Rev. Melvin Lynn Frank |
| 1941-1942 |
Rev. Albert T. Rasmussen |
| 1942-1973 |
Rev. Lauren H. Messersmith |
| 1974-???? |
Rev. Donald A. McPeek |
| ????-2005 |
Rev. Paul R. Meltzer |
| 2005-present |
Rev. Jed Watson |
